PPP Opts For “Dynasty-Based” Succession; Bilawal, Zardari To Lead Party

by matttbatard

Benazir Bhutto’s widower, Asif Ali Zardari, has been named as her successor to the Pakistan People’s Party leadership; Zardari subsequently appointed their 19 year old son, Bilawal, as party chairperson. According to Bloomberg, Zardai and Bilawal will run the party as “co-chairpersons”, with BBC News reporting that Bilawal “will take the role [of party leader] in a ceremonial capacity while he finishes his studies at Oxford University.”

More from BBC News:

Another senior party official, vice-chairman Makhdoom Amin Fahim, said Ms Bhutto had named Mr Zardari as her successor as party chairman.

But he said Mr Zardari had turned it down in favour of his son – a decision he said the party leadership had endorsed.

Mr Zardawi also announced that the couple’s children would now change their name to Bhutto.

Sitting between his father and Mr Fahim, Bilawal himself said his father would run the party while he was away at university.

But Mr Zardari blocked any further reporters’ questions to Bilawal, saying that although chairman, he was still of “tender age”.

Bloomberg also reports that, following Zardari’s announcement, “former Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif reversed his earlier decision to boycott the election, which is scheduled for Jan. 8 but may be delayed.” Zardari also said that Fahim will be the PPP candidate for Prime Minister (as TIME reported on Saturday). Neither Zardari nor Bilawal have registered as candidates for the election, thus are ineligible to run or be appointed to the position.

AFX reports that the dynastic handover wasn’t entirely free of controversy:

Bhutto’s 51-year-old sister Sanam, who was supported by many PPP members to take over, had refused to accept any responsibility in the party because of her family commitments in London, another of the officials said.

The appointment means the party leadership follows the bloodline for a third generation, some four decades after it was founded by Bilawal’s grandfather and former prime minister, Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto.

As thousands of mourners outside beat their chests in grief before the meeting started, Zardari told them: ‘Benazir Bhutto sacrificed her life for Pakistan’s survival and democracy. We will continue Bhutto’s mission.’

‘The Pakistan People’s Party will remain intact as the leading political force in the country,’ he said.

The crowd chanted slogans against President Pervez Musharraf including ‘Curse on Musharraf, Musharraf is a killer!’ outside the house in the southern village of Naudero.

But many in the crowd who had massed on the third and final official day of mourning for the 54-year-old Bhutto began chanting for Sanam Bhutto to take the reins of the party, witnesses said.

Analysts urged caution.

‘Bilawal is just 19 years old, he needs to be groomed,’ political analyst and retired general Talat Masood said. ‘They should let him complete his education.’

He warned that by opting for a ‘dynasty-based’ succession, the party risked becoming factionalised.

Political commentator Najam Sethi said Zardari would ‘run the show to keep the place warm for his son Bilawal, just like Congress party leader Sonia Gandhi is doing for her young son Rahul in India.’

PPP vice president Makhdoom Amin Fahim and the party’s Punjab province president Makhdoom Shah Mahmood Qureshi will be on a so-called ‘advisory council’ for their young leader, party officials said.

“Ceremonial”, indeed; the following sober prescription from Tariq Ali, published this past Friday, seems even more pertinent today:

To be dependent on a person or a family may be necessary at certain times, but it is a structural weakness, not a strength for a political organisation. The People’s party needs to be refounded as a modern and democratic organisation, open to honest debate and discussion, defending social and human rights, uniting the many disparate groups and individuals in Pakistan desperate for any halfway decent alternative, and coming forward with concrete proposals to stabilise occupied and war-torn Afghanistan. This can and should be done. The Bhutto family should not be asked for any more sacrifices.

As Cernig observes:

The very fact that Bhutto’s will names her 19 year old son Bilawal as her “heir” as leader of the PPP and hands the co-chairmanship to her astonishigly corrupt husband speaks volumes about Bhutto’s own preference for oligarchy over democracy.


There’s no doubt in my mind that Bhutto’s PPP aren’t the best hope for Pakistan – they’re simply the most electable. In that, they hold something very much in common with America’s Democrats and Republicans, who are also enamoured of rich oligarchies.

Update: Oh yeah, I forgot: the Bush Admin doesn’t do Plan B’s.  “Stay the course ” is more than a pithy, soundbitten catchphrase.  It’s the bedrock dogma that the Neocon gospel is built upon.

h/t Cernig.

Recommend this post at Progressive Bloggers

9 thoughts on “PPP Opts For “Dynasty-Based” Succession; Bilawal, Zardari To Lead Party

  1. The taste for oligarchy is of course a weakness, although it’s easy enough to see how that has happened in countries that have been traumatized for so long.

    I hope for Bilawal that he meets someone at Oxford who can turn him away from this cycle, to which he obviously cannot contribute anything constructive at all for a very long time, if ever. The cycle needs to stop, here and now.


  2. he obviously cannot contribute anything constructive at all for a very long time, if ever

    I think that’s the point; Mr Ten Percent and the rest of the caretakers needed to install a figurehead with the Bhutto name (hence the hasty name change for Zardari and Benazir’s offspring) to allow for a smooth transition. There’s no way the general public (to say nothing of many PPP diehards) would accept Zardari as outright party leader. Bilawal’s leadership position truly is ceremonial.

    Also, The fact that no mention has been made of the still-deposed/detained supreme court justices speaks volumes about the legitimacy (or lack thereof) of the upcoming sham election so fervently desired by the Pakistani status quo and self-intrested Western imperialists.

    (Oh, and Sharif sure didn’t waste time changing course with the shifting political winds, eh? Talk about a expedient 180.)

    Your conviction that the Cheneyites would continue to stick with the (now-former) Good General no matter what seems to have been vindicated.

    ”Like a dog that returns to its vomit Is a fool who repeats his folly.”

    And effing how.


  3. Hey, where are Ghinwa and Fatima Bhutto in the scale of things? There is also Murtaza Jr.

    Are they the rebel faction within the family?


  4. Are they the rebel faction within the family?

    Pretty much. As noted by Tariq Ali and William Dalrymple, Ghinwa and Fatima both despised Benazir, convinced she and Zardari was complicit in the death of Murtaza Sr. Benazir’s mother, Nusrat, shared the sentiments of her daughter-in-law and granddaughter re: Bhutto. Of her (now-late) daughter, Nusrat once said “I had no idea I had nourished a viper in my breast.”

    Not exactly the folks Benazir would hand-pick to continue the family legacy.


  5. Well, Murtaza was a bit of a hot head himself. He was noted for hijacking a Pakistani airliner into Kabul in return for freeing political prisoners. Of course, there were rumours of links through Ghinwa with the Assad family in Syria. Not a branch of the family that the US and the UK would like to have influence in Pakistan.

    As of today, Fatima is the most articulate of the third generation Bhuttos (we are still talking about this in 2007????) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fatima_Bhutto. Links to some progressive writings. Still, if Pakistani democracy is dependent on a 19 year old frosh from Oxford, then that nation state will continue to be a primary exporter of taxi drivers in the Western world.


  6. “Pity the nation whose sages are dumb with years and whose strong men are yet in the cradle”, rightly said by Khalil Gibran. Still wondering whether it is PPP (Pakistan Peoples Party) or PBP (Pakistan Bhuttos’ Party)?


  7. PS: Even if it is family legacy case, who is most deserving? Intellectual Fatima or Imprudent Bilawal?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s