Supreme Court of Canada Unanimously Defrosts Libel Chill

by matttbastard

The Globe & Mail:

The media should not live in constant fear of facing a libel suit every time a provocative commentary is published or broadcast, the Supreme Court of Canada said yesterday in a major ruling won by controversial Vancouver radio broadcaster Rafe Mair.

In a 9-0 decision that modernizes the defence of fair comment, the court found that Mr. Mair did not defame Christian-values advocate Kari Simpson when he denounced her stand on a book-banning controversy.

“An individual’s reputation is not to be treated as regrettable but unavoidable roadkill on the highway of public controversy, but nor should an overly solicitous regard for personal reputation be permitted to ‘chill’ freewheeling debate on matters of public interest,” Mr. Justice Ian Binnie said.

Judge Binnie said that the key to a defence of honest belief – particularly in an era when extravagant overstatement is common – should lie in whether an honest person could have held the same opinion.

“We live in a free country, where people have as much right to express outrageous and ridiculous opinions as moderate ones,” Judge Binnie said. “In much modern media, personalities such as Rafe Mair are as much entertainers as journalists.”

Score one for the chronically hyperbolic Canadian media personalities who live and die on the alter of outrageous and ridiculous opinions (ahem).

H/t The Robert Bond Papers

Recommend this post at Progressive Bloggers

5 thoughts on “Supreme Court of Canada Unanimously Defrosts Libel Chill

  1. Do you think that the same thing will happen to Harper’s suing the Liberal party ,will get the same response when it comes to them publishing on their website?


  2. lol, Binnie is rather hilarious. I like his use of the highly legal technical term “roadkill”.
    Hard to imagine Scalia saying this, eh, even though he’d likely come to the same conclusion. Hell, SCOTUS wouldn’t even bother hearing a case like this.
    And annie, it’s hard for me to think of what someone would have to say to defame Harper!


  3. And annie, it’s hard for me to think of what someone would have to say to defame Harper!

    That his middle name is ‘Hussein’ and that as a child he attended a Madrassa in Indonesia?

    Show us your birth certificate, Steve (or should I say “Muhammed”?)


  4. Yes, Binnie’s language is wonderful. He slips that great zinger about current journalism in too. Heh. And I write as someone whose reputation has just spent a couple of days as roadkill … ;-)


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s