Antonia Zerbisias, Kathy English, and #TorStarFAIL: Great Expectations
One thing about keeping your expectations low: more often than not, they’ll be met. This was certainly the case this past Saturday, as our old friend Kathy English, public editor for the venerable Toronto Star, offered a tepid, passive-aggressive non-apology to Star columnist Antonia Zerbisias. Zerb, as you may recall, had been sandbagged in a column written by English (in concert with Star publisher and scourge to uppity female opinion scribes, John Cruickshank) after Canadian Jewish Congress (CJC) head Bernie Farber decided to concern-troll the Star editorial board — and succeeded.
After a vocal outcry, both online and in numerous letters to the editor (two of which were quietly published this past Wednesday, a far-lower circulation day than the prominent Saturday edition where the original column appeared), English revisited the matter this weekend — by whinging about snark and incivility:
It is the opinion of some blogger in Abu Dhabi [aka former Star employee, Jen Gerson, who responds to English's incivil swipe here], upon reading my column of last week, that I am a “disconnected crony.”
Other bloggers labelled me “priggish,” overly “earnest” and expressed the view that my column is evidence that “old media are still painfully unaware of how blogs operate.”
An online commenter said I should have known that a comment posted by Star columnist Antonia Zerbisias on her blog, which I consider inappropriate for publication by this news organization, was simply the “snark – irony, sarcasm,” of the blogosphere.
I learned much about “snark” and nasty blogosphere invective this week from some bloggers who disagree with my take on what Zerbisias wrote. Mean-spirited personal attack, inaccurate facts, innuendo and even speculation about the identity of my spouse was lobbed my way, much of it anonymously.
Most of what I read simply reinforced my view that blogs produced by professional journalists working under the brand banner of a “mainstream” news organization such as the Star must aspire to far higher standards than what’s emerging elsewhere in the blogosphere.
A good start would be, oh, I dunno, aspiring to make sure you have the whole story before drawing a conclusion:
Here’s the fuller context that explains why she wrote this: Zerbisias had seen Farber marching in the Pride parade wearing a T-shirt that said, “Nobody knows I’m gay.” She didn’t include that information in her blog so readers didn’t know that context. Nor did she tell me that when I showed her my column before publication.
In complaining to the Star, neither did Farber think to tell me that he, along with dozens of others who marched with the Kulanu group, had worn a T-shirt that made its own ironic quip. That’s context I sure wish I had known.
This makes it clear to me that Zerbisias’s comment was intended as sarcastic irony, stock in trade for this columnist and blogger. But I think her attempt at irony failed here; the quip – as published without that context – was ambiguous and could be misunderstood.
And yet the only person who seemed to misunderstand the quip was you and Cruickshank (shit, I bet even ol’ Bernie is a Seinfeld fan). Just because your reading comprehension is substandard is no reason to assume that others share your deficiency, Kathy.
Anyway, moving on:
To be fair to Zerbisias, it should be made clear, though, that she did not “make things up,” as Farber interpreted it. “I don’t `make things up’ – ever,” she said, adding that there “is a lot of space between publishing falsehoods and spouting irony.”
The principle of my column last week remains. Toronto Star journalists simply can’t engage in this hurly-burly tone of the blogosphere if it confuses readers or doesn’t meet the Star‘s journalistic standards. As publisher John Cruickshank told several readers this week: “It creates confusion about how committed we are to the truth and gets imbued with too much seriousness because we are the Star.
Shorter: “Bloggers are MEAN, the DOG ate my homework, and, goddammit, I’m STILL RIGHT!!1one”
Cover your ears, kids–that sonic boom you heard was from the F-16-like point swooping over English’s head.
Dawg, who, late last week, modestly proposed that English’s original column was in fact a Machiavellian plot to make Farber and Cruickshank look like dunces, reassesses his previous bestowal of the benefit of the doubt to English:
Blogs are indeed different from common-or-garden reportage: “hurly-burly” sums it up quite nicely. But editors and publishers are loath to relinquish control, which means that in-house bloggers are forced to look over their shoulders while we in the blogosphere proper are not.
The chilling effect here is palpable: recall that we aren’t even talking about a post, but a comment thread. Ethics and professionalism, both of which Zerb wears on her sleeve, by the way, are not what this is about at all. Rather, it’s precisely what an observer quoted by English says: “old media are still painfully unaware of how blogs operate.”Different languages: different ways of engaging in print; different styles.
But the same ethical and professional standards, pace English, at least for those of us who take the craft seriously. On that point, when she dug around a little more, assisted by hordes of outraged commentators, bloggers and Star correspondents, she discovered that Zerb hadn’t transgressed any ethical or professional codes whatsoever, and had to be content with complaining about her alleged ambiguity. That’s fair comment, I suppose, but a far cry from her original assertions. So why is she even raising the question of standards, leaving the impression, despite her earlier disclaimer, that Zerb had violated them?
Worse, readers are condescended to: none of that hurly-burly stuff for us if it “confuses” us. I submit that no one in this wildly overblown affair was remotely confused. That’s a dodge, plain and simple.
Dave further articulates the bottom line that English has apparently allowed her easily-bruised ego to obscure:
I could fire back with two words, which English would dismiss as evidence supporting her current view. So, I’ll say this: We are your readers, Ms. English.
The “new media” and the bloggers English decided to castigate are the same people that used to sit around the kitchen table bitching about things read in newspapers and whose only recourse was to submit a letter to the very organ and editor with whom they took issue.
It was a one-sided arrangement that left communicative readers at the mercy of “edited for brevity” or without a voice at all. What English doesn’t like is that we like this process a whole lot better. Further, because of the “new media” we are able to communicate directly with the principle subjects of stories and columns – and do. I’m sure that sends chills down the spines of newspaper editors because their worst nightmare has come true: continuous and unrelenting scrutiny, and continuous and unrelenting criticism – some of it accompanied by the language spoken around the kitchen table.
Here’s the thing, Kathy: you fucked up.
You fucked up big.
You guys got played by an experienced player with an agenda who used your forum as Public Editor as a platform to launch a heated proxy missive against a respected Star columnist. Contrary to your defensive posturing, this is not really about the online rabble, new media vs. old, or the ‘ethics’ of snark; this is about your responsibility as a journalist to gather all the facts before accusing one of your colleagues of making shit up — a charge that, if substantiated, is, I would wager, a fireable offense at any newspaper and thus very serious.
By not gathering the relevant information beforehand (namely, Farber’s highly public–and self-promoted–appearance at Toronto Pride 2009 wearing a t-shirt glibly pronouncing his apparently facetious life on the down-low), you subjugated that responsibility and gravely damaged Zerbisias’ reputation. Saying that neither Farber nor Zerbisias were immediately forthcoming with said information is a cheap cop-out; a five-minute Google search (much like the one likely conducted by SOME BLOGGER IN TORONTO) would have helped unearth the buried info that you now acknowledge exonerates Zerbisias (though you still claim that your original charges are somehow still valid. Logic is apparently an unprofessional blogger conceit).
One can imagine the chill mentioned by Dawg is quite palpable right now in the Star newsroom, as reporters and columnists must be asking themselves: Can the public editor, editor-in-chief and publisher be trusted to protect their staff against spurious charges lodged by special interests trying to muzzle the press?
Many of them, I would wager, feel their trust has been betrayed.
By allowing a lobbyist to dictate the editorial response to an off-hand, ironic remark, your ability to sift between legitimate and manufactured grievance is now in question, Kathy. And by not addressing your dereliction of duty in an open, transparent manner, you aren’t exactly making us brim over with confidence that you do in fact recognize the gravity of your failure. Quite the opposite, in fact.
So, until that moment of epiphany occurs, be advised, Kathy, that your readers — the hurly-burly, rambunctious, unprofessional online rabble that you scorn — will be watching. This isn’t personal; the dissemination of accurate information is imperative for any democracy to properly function. It is in the public interest to have a press corps free of self-censorship, unencumbered by the fear that the ideology of special interests will dictate their output to the detriment of a vibrant, free press.
As Corvin Russell notes, you owed Antonia Zerbisias an apology for defaming her professional reputation as a journalist and for not protecting her from a bad-faith political attack. But, like Dave said, you also owe us, the Star readership, an apology: for not providing us with all the relevant information; for allowing a lobby group to influence your editorial mandate; and for doing a piss-poor job of representing our interest. Y’know, what they pay you the big bucks for.
It is going to take time to restore confidence in your ability, for both your staff and readers; this time, the expectations are monumentally greater.
Tags: #TorStarFAIL, accuracy, Antonia Zerbisias, Bernie Farber, blog!blog!blog!, blogging, Canadian Jewish Congress, ethics, gay panic, homophobia, John Cruickshank, journalism, Kathy English, new media, social media, Toronto Pride, Toronto Star
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Licence.
- As @pmharper disingenuously drapes laurels on Madiba, the 411 on his old pro-apartheid org, The Northern Foundation pushedleft.blogspot.ca/2009/09/stephe… 35 minutes ago
- RT @jimbobbysez: @cbcnews @ctvnews Not 1 mention of Harper being a founder of the pro-aparteid, anti-Mandela Northern Foundation?! #cdnpoli 38 minutes ago
- No, Caitlin Dewey, it wasn't the EEK! Commie-cooties -- it was the White Supremacy, stupid washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-fix/… #JimCrowIntl #Mandela 44 minutes ago
- AM must-read by @Okwonga: "Dear revisionists, #Mandela will never, ever be your minstrel." okwonga.com/?p=869 #Madiba 55 minutes ago
- 4 in 10 say 'NBD.' Welp. RT @eNCAnews: White South Africans in apartheid denial enca.com/south-africa/w… h/t @RachelDecoste #Madiba #Mandela 1 hour ago
- MT @Hesiod2k11: Keep in mind, the Brits once viewed George Washington much the same way rightwing idiots view Mandela. #uppers @upwithsteve 1 hour ago
- Flashback: Anders is weally, weally gwumpy when he first wakes up cbc.ca/m/touch/canada… #cdnpoli #humanpiles #babyssleeping 3 hours ago
- Rip Van Anders owned by fellow Harpercon over Anders' stubborn, vestigial wingnut scorn for Madiba cbc.ca/m/touch/news/s… #cdnpoli 3 hours ago
- RT @areviaki: @matttbastard @ugottabekiddin I propose we change the definition from #Santorum to #RobAnders #Oxford #Webster #wikipedia #c… 13 hours ago
- RT @History_Pics: Nelson #Mandela February 11th, 1992 http://t.co/26WnNXB75B 13 hours ago
- Rip Van Anders: still an oozing fissure on the sphincter of Canada's far right huffingtonpost.ca/2013/12/06/rob… #cdnpoli #Mandela #RIPMadiba 14 hours ago
- RT @j0_mAmA: #LdnOnt: I am SO excited for tomorrow's #OEVLdn Craft Fair showcasing wonderful local artists & crafters. Please join us! 10-4… 15 hours ago
- Fmr Cdn PM Brian Mulroney: "“I viewed apartheid w/ the same degree of disgust that I attached to the Nazis" thestar.com/news/world/201… #cdnpoli 15 hours ago
- "#Mandela’s example is a ringing endorsement of what is derisively known as the “great man school of history”" commentarymagazine.com/2013/12/05/the… 21 hours ago
- Bam. RT @TheAtlantic: Apartheid's useful idiots: Ta-Nehisi Coates on the Americans who failed Nelson Mandela theatln.tc/1cqm7WR 21 hours ago
- Teabaggers turn on (ex?) darling Ted Cruz after Facebook homage to that notorious NEEEGROOO Marxist, Nelson #Mandela thegrio.com/2013/12/06/ted… 21 hours ago
- MT @picardonhealth Intimate, Raw and Revealing: Nelson #Mandela as you've never heard him before on @CBCideas cbc.ca/ideas/themande… 21 hours ago
- RT @HarryWaisbren: Wow, Upworthy hits almost 2x as many unique views vs previous record: pando.com/2013/12/05/new… “@Upworthy posts go viral b… 21 hours ago
- CBC News - How Nelson Mandela found inspiration in Canada cbc.ca/m/touch/news/s… 1 day ago
- RT @RachelDecoste: #Mandela's fight for racial equality continues here in #Canada. huff.to/ISFxZZ via @HuffPostCanada #cdnpoli 1 day ago
- Monday Metal: Satan – Life Sentence
- Cinerama – ‘I Wake Up Screaming’ (AUDIO)
- Fucking Up Young (Aging Hipster Rewind)
- Around the Internets: Monday Jump-Off
- More Collateral Damage From USia’s Wars
- Abdul Haji: Hero. Muslim. BAMF.
- So Who Are They Assigning Down The Hall Anyway?
- A strange and bitter crop, indeed.
- Monday Metal: Atheist – Unquestionable Presence
- What Was Justin Trudeau Smoking When He Decided To Embrace Marijuana Legaliza — Oh, Never Mind.
- The Atomic Road To Damascus (With a Detour Through Goldsboro)
- Hilzoy Speak, You Listen
- Privilege In A Nutshell (Or, There You Go Again, Richard Dawkins)
- Stand ALL Yr Groundz (UPDATED)
- Harpercons to Small Live Music Venue Owners: Drop Dead
- Obama has shown how a future GOP president can gut Obamacare (Philip Klein/Washington Examiner) December 7, 2013
- Those Media Hysterics Who Said Obama's Presidency Was Dead Were Wrong. Again. (Alec Macgillis/The New Republic) December 7, 2013
- Rand Paul Says Wife is Against a 2016 Run (Arlette Saenz/ABC News) December 7, 2013
- Charlie Cook: This is one of the most dramatic shifts in a generic congressional ballot I've ever seen (Jeffdunetz/Hot Air) December 7, 2013
- U.S. extends permit for eagle deaths (Dina Cappiello/Associated Press) December 7, 2013
- Third Way Op-Ed Writer Says Elizabeth Warren's Backing Of Social Security Plan Was The 'Final Moment' (Luke Johnson/The Huffington Post) December 7, 2013
- Slowly They Modernize: A Federal Agency That Still Uses Floppy Disks (Jada F. Smith/New York Times) December 7, 2013
- Doctors boycotting California's Obamacare exchange (Richard Pollock/Washington Examiner) December 7, 2013
- Ted Cruz · 562,730 like this (Facebook) December 7, 2013
- The Democratic Party: How It Can Save Itself (Ted Van Dyk/The Atlantic Online) December 7, 2013
- Montreal Simon: The Montreal Massacre and the Con War on Women December 7, 2013
- accidentaldeliberations: Musical interlude December 7, 2013
- Cathie from Canada: Solidarity forever December 7, 2013
- Fat and Not Afraid: LoZ: A Link Between Worlds December 7, 2013
- Creekside: "A special committee that will have the right Senators on board" December 7, 2013
- Hard Science Fiction Makes a Comeback in Fox’s Almost Human Emily Manuel
- Israel’s Prawer Plan Brings A Second Nakba for Palestinian Bedouin Feature Writer
- Gravity and the 21st Century Hollywood Universe Feature Writer
- Fighting U.S. Imperialism With… Sexism and Racism? Mastodon’s Thanksgiving Shirt Causes Controversy Feature Writer
- Co-Directing Couple Joe Brewster and Michèle Stephenson on Race, Elite Education and their Sundance-winning “American Promise” Feature Writer
- OPSEU Diablogue: $110k Owen Sound MPP shrugs off 6-year PSW wage freeze, calls for two years more December 7, 2013 opseudiablogue
- Melissa Fong: Weekend Party Announcement- Ben Klock in Toronto- 2013 BLOGCEMBER 7/31 December 7, 2013 Melissa Fong aka @InternationalMF
- BigCityLib Strikes Back: Northern Gateway Set To Heat Up December 7, 2013 bigcitylib
- Canadian Trends: It’s official: The global banking cartel is a cartel December 7, 2013 Richard
- Wise Law Blog: Glenn Greenwald on the Complacency of Corporate Law Partners December 7, 2013 Garry Wise
- Montreal Simon: The Montreal Massacre and the Con War on Women December 7, 2013 Simon
- Accidental Deliberations: Musical interlude December 7, 2013 Greg Fingas
- Cathie from Canada: Solidarity forever December 7, 2013 CathiefromCanada
- daveberta.ca - Alberta politics: Redford’s Christmas cabinet shuffle December 7, 2013 daveberta
- Bene Diction Blogs On: Mark Driscoll plagiarism debate twists and turns December 7, 2013 Bene Diction
- R U able to buy RU486 in Canada? Why not?* December 4, 2013 email@example.com (fern hill)
- A peace exhibition that highlights warmongers and some peace activism... November 30, 2013 firstname.lastname@example.org (deBeauxOs)
- Coming soon: CON revisionist history, with a dump of tarsands on the side. November 25, 2013 email@example.com (deBeauxOs)
- Time to Roast #PeterPeeper November 23, 2013 firstname.lastname@example.org (fern hill)
- So prophetic, so appropriate. November 22, 2013 email@example.com (deBeauxOs)
- Hate Group Ties Become Issue for Tony Perkins in Possible Run for Congress December 6, 2013 Josh Glasstetter
- David Duke Tossed Out of Another European Country December 6, 2013 Heidi Beirich
- Craig Cobb Sent to North Dakota State Hospital for Mental Evaluation December 5, 2013 Ryan Lenz
- Rep. Randy Forbes Is Unfit to Serve – as Chairman December 5, 2013 Josh Glasstetter
- Suffolk County, N.Y., Police Department Reaches Agreement with DOJ to Reform Hate Crime Practices December 4, 2013 Heidi Beirich
- South Africa: COSATU pays tribute to Comrade Madiba December 6, 2013
- Qatar: Following a catalogue of condemnation, a real chance for change in Qatar December 5, 2013
- Europe: Americanized Labor Policy Is Spreading in Europe December 4, 2013
- Korea (South): Defend the Right to Strike of Korean Rail Workers December 4, 2013
- Global: SPECIAL REPORT: Rio Tinto unsustainable business practice December 4, 2013
- Picture Of The Day December 7, 2013 War News Updates Editor
- The CIA's Secret Art Collection December 7, 2013 War News Updates Editor
- A List of All The Wars Since 1900 December 7, 2013 War News Updates Editor
- This Is China's Weakness December 7, 2013 War News Updates Editor
- A Look At Britain's Role In America's 'Dirty Wars' (Commentary) December 7, 2013 War News Updates Editor
- War News for Saturday, November 07, 2013 December 7, 2013 firstname.lastname@example.org (whisker)
- War News for friday, November 06, 2013 December 6, 2013 email@example.com (whisker)
- War News for Thursday, November 05, 2013 December 5, 2013 firstname.lastname@example.org (whisker)
- War News for Wednesday, November 04, 2013 December 4, 2013 email@example.com (whisker)
- War News for Tuesday, November 03, 2013 December 3, 2013 firstname.lastname@example.org (whisker)
- War News for Monday, November 02, 2013 December 2, 2013 email@example.com (whisker)
- News of the Day for Sunday, December 1, 2013 December 1, 2013 firstname.lastname@example.org (Cervantes)
- War News for Saturday, November 30, 2013 November 30, 2013 email@example.com (whisker)
- War News for Friday, November 29, 2013 November 29, 2013 firstname.lastname@example.org (whisker)
- War News for Thursday, November 28, 2013 November 28, 2013 email@example.com (whisker)
- Iranian Sanctions Easing to Benefit India December 7, 2013 James
- Manila’s Defense Conundrum December 7, 2013 James
- China’s ADIZ and the Japan-US response December 7, 2013 James
- Qantas in Trouble December 6, 2013 James
- Capitalism: The Right Way to Promote Democracy December 6, 2013 Zachary
- Emerging Markets: Stronger for Longer? December 6, 2013 James
- Asia Mourns Nelson Mandela December 6, 2013 Ankit
- Armed With SARS Lessons, China Fights H7N9 Bird Flu December 6, 2013 Shannon
- New Russian Air-to-Air Missiles Will Field Almost Perfect Accuracy December 6, 2013 Ankit
- The TPP’s Not Dead Yet (But It’s Close) December 6, 2013 Shannon
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
- Outlawing The January 25 Revolution (VIDEO) December 7, 2013 Mosireen
- Augmented Airspace: A Project by Dia Hamed and Lot Amoros December 6, 2013 Medrar TV مدرار تي في
- القراءة المبكرة December 5, 2013 Osama Esber أسامة إسبر
- Devastation Is Upon Us December 4, 2013 Omar Robert Hamilton
- New Texts Out Now: Ralf Brand and Sara Fregonese, The Radicals’ City: Urban Environment, Polarization, Cohesion December 4, 2013 Sara Fregonese
- Twenty Years of Talks: Keeping Palestine Occupied December 4, 2013 Visualizing Palestine
- Arabian Peninsula Media Roundup (December 3) December 3, 2013 Arabian Peninsula Page Editors
- هل تحتاج الثورة إلى قانون للتظاهر؟ December 3, 2013 George Giacaman جورج جقمان
- Sonbol in Sinai: A Narrative of Territorialization December 3, 2013 Ahmad Hosni
- Turkey Media Roundup (December 3) December 3, 2013 Turkey Page Editors
- Nelson Mandela: see the movement he personified as well as the man December 7, 2013 Peter McColl
- The student protests this week mark the handover to a new generation December 7, 2013 James McAsh
- Is slavery invincible? December 6, 2013 Mukunda Kattel
- India’s questionable choices of icons December 6, 2013 N. Jayaram
- In defense of Otpor December 6, 2013 Ivan Marovic
- Alternative horizons - understanding Occupy's politics December 6, 2013 Adrian Wilding, Richard Gunn and R.C. Smith
- Inspired by the public December 6, 2013 Sandra Boks
- Bradford’s Community University: co-producing knowledge for a change December 6, 2013 Jenny Pearce
- Starving the roots of women’s human rights groups December 6, 2013 Angelika Arutyunova
- Smashing egoism: against flashpoint action December 6, 2013 Bellamy
- October 2013
- September 2013
- August 2013
- June 2013
- May 2013
- March 2013
- February 2013
- January 2013
- December 2012
- July 2012
- June 2012
- May 2012
- April 2012
- February 2012
- December 2011
- November 2011
- September 2011
- August 2011
- May 2011
- February 2011
- December 2010
- September 2010
- August 2010
- June 2010
- May 2010
- April 2010
- March 2010
- February 2010
- January 2010
- December 2009
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
- March 2008
- February 2008
- January 2008
- December 2007
- November 2007
- October 2007
- September 2007
- August 2007
- July 2007
- June 2007
- May 2007
- April 2007
- March 2007
- February 2007
- January 2007
- December 2006
- November 2006